California Says 10MPH Over the Speed Limit is Enough

Would you want your car to notify and alert you if you were driving 10 mph over the speed limit? California is considering Senate Bill 961, which would require all new vehicles sold after 2030 to have a speed alert system. While some view this as a significant step toward improving road safety, others are raising concerns about its potential drawbacks. If you want to read the bill, click here.

Under this proposal, every passenger vehicle, motor truck, and bus in California would need a passive intelligent speed assistance system. This system alerts drivers with visual and audio signals if they were driving 10 mph over the limit. Sounds beneficial, but does it truly deliver on its promise?

The Debate: Safety vs. Practicality

Supporters believe this technology could reduce speeding-related accidents. Senator Scott Wiener points out that over 400 Californians die annually in speed-related incidents, labeling the bill as a vital response to a “traffic safety crisis.” However, a growing number of critics are voicing their concerns through petitions. Here are some key points of contention:

• Increased Variation: Critics argue that speed limiters might create more dangerous driving conditions. Research shows that speed variations can lead to accidents, while consistent—even slightly above the limit—are generally safer.
• Collision Risks: Detractors highlight that limiting flexibility may hinder drivers’ emergency responses. Quick acceleration can be crucial to avoid collisions, and restricting this ability could increase danger.
• Emergency Situations: In critical moments, such as rushing someone to the hospital, every second counts. The proposed law could inadvertently delay urgent medical transport, risking lives.

Will It Change Your Driving Habits?

While SB 961 aims to encourage safer driving, it may not change habits for many drivers. Those who drive over the limit often might simply disable the alerts. Manufacturers could offer advanced features, but unless consumers demand them, many may only implement the minimum requirements.

Could a speed alert system genuinely enhance road safety, or would it become just another feature that drivers ignore? Achieving safer roads may require a mix of technology, driver education, and effective law enforcement, rather than relying solely on speeding alerts.